Carly likes life on the wild side and agrees to a ménage with Ranger and Drew. The guys realize they feel something strong for Carly, but aren't sure if she feels the same way. Ranger thinks she won't go for a three-way relationship because of her career and urges Drew to pursue her on his own, but Drew is having none of that. He wants it all.
They take a long weekend trip together to Austin to explore her comfort with being seen with two men and find that she's fine with it. But just as they begin to hope things will work out, word gets back to her bosses that she's in a threesome relationship. They threaten to fire her. Carly loves her career as a dental hygienist. Is the love of two men enough, or will she choose her career over love?